Wait, They Actually Picked These Guys As ‘Sexiest Man Alive’? Let’s See Who Nailed It!

Idris showed up looking classy, cool, and just straight-up charming. Basically, the textbook sexy guy that everyone could get behind.

Right around his James Bond prime, Brosnan was the smooth, classy type - think shaken, not stirred, with a side of silver fox vibes.

After channeling Thor and rocking that hammer (and his muscles), Chris was basically the god of sexy for a hot minute.

Wolverine’s got claws and charm! Hugh was muscle and wit wrapped into one handsome package, and everyone was here for it.

Brad won it twice! Once at ’95 and again here, rocking that Fight Club bod and that famous Jennifer Aniston era glow-up. Classic move.

Pirates of the Caribbean made Johnny the captain of cool, rocking the bad-boy look that had us all hooked.

Clooney snagged the crown twice, same as Brad. This time as the silver fox everyone's jealous of - but totally respected.

The first openly gay man to score the title! Jonathan’s the fresh new face bringing sexy into 2025, and we’re here for it.

Paul’s charm is basically endless - and he even joked about finally getting invited to those 'sexy dinners' with Clooney and Pitt. We believe it!

Johnny took the crown again, but this time people were like, 'Haven’t we done this one before?' Still, he looked amazing!

Michael finally shook off the ‘always next in line’ jacket and owned it. His fans say he’s a top 5 sexy legend - no arguments here!

Magic Mike made Channing a household name, and 2012 was his official ‘Yep, I’m Hollywood’s leading heartthrob’ moment.

Ryan’s got the jokes and the looks - that combo hit just right exactly when People made the list younger and funnier.

Matt joked about rocking a ‘gut’ on screen, but fans loved his chill, rugged vibe. Definitely sexy in that laid-back, ‘alright, alright, alright’ kinda way.

Captain America himself snagged the title and called it a ‘weird form of humble brag.’ We say, mission accomplished!

From Limitless to Hangover fame, Bradley was Hollywood’s ‘guy next door’ turned serious heartthrob.

The soccer star is one of the few athletes to win, but some fans wondered why the award wasn’t strictly Hollywood territory. Still, those looks score goals anytime.

John’s win was announced with a wink and a nudge on The Late Show, basically saying, ‘Sexy? Sure, why not?’ Plus, rumor has it Glen Powell might've said no - spicy!

The Rock rolled in after Moana and during Baywatch and Jumanji buzz. Some loved his giant charm, others thought it was a bit much - but hey, he rocks!

Nearly 20 years after being McDreamy on Grey’s Anatomy, Patrick finally got his official sexy crown on Jimmy Kimmel Live. Dream officially achieved!

Here’s a fun tidbit: his co-star at the time called him 'the most beautiful man who ever walked the earth.' High praise or what?

Ben was riding high from Good Will Hunting and had just married J.Lo - Hollywood’s sweetheart and macho combo all in one package.

Matt’s the everyman who made it cool to be cute but sexy at the same time - though some swore he was more cute than hot. Tomato, tomahto!

First band frontman on the list! Adam’s rockstar swagger and The Voice fame made him the sexy singer we didn’t know we needed.

Blake’s win got people talking (and some shouting 'huh?'). Country music star or sexy icon? You decide.

John Legend blew up with his EGOT status but his spot on the sexy list sparked opinions. Love him or question him, he sure made noise!