8 WTF Moments That Made This True Crime Doc Way More Confusing Than Creepy

The 911 call in this story is straight up bizarre. The caller kept saying one of the victims was "not waking up," even though the cops later found a full-on murder scene. Redditor TheClassics was like, “Huh? That makes zero sense.”

Turns out, friends were so confused they originally thought maybe it was just someone passed out from too much partying. One buddy actually knew the victims were dead but told the others to just say they were unconscious so no one freaked out prematurely.

Basically, everyone was shock-level disoriented, and the documentary just skipped over this confusing explanation. Talk about missing the juicy part of the drama!

How did a random white Hyundai Elantra point straight to Kohberger? The doc jumps from a blurry car to a name without showing the middle steps - and Redditors noticed.

Apparently, cops found Kohberger because he owned a white Hyundai that matched the suspect car. Then they noticed he’d changed his car registration, took a suspicious trip, and started acting left of center.

But some people think the documentary glossed this part too quickly, leaving them feeling like the car connection was a bit of a jump. Sneak peek: the car was cleaner inside than your grandma’s china cabinet.

DNA was a big deal here, but the doc makes it sound like they nailed the case just by swabbing some trash. TheClassics points out the difference between using DNA to sniff out a suspect and DNA proof that seals the deal in court.

The truth? They had to work backwards - first, family DNA to chase leads, then Kohberger’s DNA matched the crime scene. But the doc kinda glossed over those twists and pauses in the process.

Bonus weird: some Redditors wondered if a lone attacker was really responsible since DNA of victims didn’t mix the way you'd expect if one knife went through them all.

After Kohberger was caught, TheClassics was waiting for the doc to say, “Yep, we swabbed him, and it was a match.” But nope, that line never came.

Redditors had to chime in: yes, they took cheek swabs and confirmed the DNA matched the knife sheath at the scene - like, well beyond a reasonable doubt.

Plus, it turns out there was a lot more DNA than anyone expected - not some sparse “trace” stuff. The DNA evidence was actually pretty darn impressive.

Still, some folks weren’t buying it, wondering why there was no blood or fibers linking Kohberger to the crime spots in his car or apartment. So yeah, some questions still hanging in the air.

The roommate Dylan Mortensen saw the suspect and locked eyes with him - and then just went back into her room? It sounds nuts.

The doc notes this but quickly brushes over it, leaving folks wondering why she didn’t just yell or call the cops right then.

Turns out, trauma is a lot stranger than TV makes it look. People freeze, doubt what they see, or try to pretend it's a nightmare.

Some think she froze in shock; others think maybe this was a targeted attack and the killer didn’t expect her to be home. Either way, the trauma hit hard - these roommates are still putting themselves back together today.

Here’s a wild thought: the doc says the whole horrific attack happened in about 8 to 10 minutes. That’s like the time it takes to binge a quick TikTok session.

TheClassics thought it sounded impossible to murder four people, move through floors, and escape all that fast.

But Reddit detectives pointed out maybe the killer was super familiar with the place - perhaps even had been inside before - which explains the speed.

Others say the timeline might be off since phone GPS info may tell a different tale, but the takeaway is that yes, this nightmare all played out faster than your morning coffee ritual.

The doc spent a bunch of time on Kohberger being socially awkward, creepy, and mysterious - but TheClassics thought that was a weird flex when it came to proving guilt.

But other watchers said these personality tidbits help explain a possible motive - like maybe Kohberger was a controlling, narcissistic weirdo who wanted to see if he could get away with terrible crimes.

There are reports from classmates and neighbors that he stalked women, made folks uncomfortable, and seemed totally obsessed.

Turns out 'weird' is just the tip of this iceberg.

The doc drops that Kohberger bought the murder weapon on Amazon and then moves along like it’s no big deal. TheClassics wanted receipts.

Turns out, investigators did get electronic warrants and checked his Amazon purchase history, finding a Ka-Bar knife and sheath ordered to his apartment.

Plus, they couldn’t find any fingerprints on the sheath but followed DNA clues instead. The doc didn’t dig into this much, but Reddit sleuths filled in the blanks.

So yeah, Amazon’s tracking your knives, whether you like it or not.